Hungry for pizza in Kansas City? Here's a guide to the city's many shops and styles (2023)

This story was first published in KCUR's Creative Adventure newsletter. You cansign up to receive stories like this in your inbox every Tuesday.

Pizza could be considered the third pillar of Kansas City’s culinary milieu, ranking just below barbecue and tacos.

Being in a food lover’s city, many of us have pretty impassioned opinions about pizza — even beyond the question of whether pineapple belongs on it or not.

We’ll leave those debates up to you, while we explore some of the various pizza styles available in Kansas City. Along the way you might recognize your favorite parlor, or a pie purveyor that’s brand new to you.

Consider this your passport to a world of pizza styles (and an excuse to try them all).

Neapolitan pizza

Hungry for pizza in Kansas City? Here's a guide to the city's many shops and styles (1)

1889 Pizza Napoletana

/

Modern pizza as we know it can be traced back to Naples, Italy. That’s where our journey begins. Flatbreads with various toppings were an inexpensive and nutritious food sold at street stalls to people working low-wage jobs.

These first Neapolitan pizzas were made with simple ingredients such as garlic, lard and salt, and perhaps a bit of cheese and basil.

In 1522, Spaniards brought tomatoes from the Americas to Europe. By mid-century, people in Naples began using tomatoes as an ingredient and changed the course of Neapolitan pizza. Today’s traditional Neapolitan pizza features a crust made with flour, yeast, water and salt. The sauce is prepared with San Marzano tomatoes and salt.

In Kansas City, fans of Neapolitan pizza have several options. Craig Jones, the co-owner of 451 Pizza, recommends il Lazzarone in the River Market and 1889 Pizza Napoletana near Westwood in Kansas City, Kansas. Both restaurants serve traditional style wood-fired Neapolitan pies.

Rafi Chaudry, CEO of Torn Label Brewing Co., has traveled to cities across the U.S. in search of different pizza styles. Here at home, he recommends Devoured, a local pizza pop-up that brings its “Neapolitan-esque pizzas” directly to customers through various pop-up and private events.

“The crust at Devoured is rightfully the star on their pizzas,” says Chaudry. “I love the creativity on display at their pop-ups just as much as the dough.”

Pizza margherita

Hungry for pizza in Kansas City? Here's a guide to the city's many shops and styles (2)

il Lazzarone Pizza

/

When King Umberto I and Queen Margherita visited Naples in 1889, pizzaiolo Raffaele Esposito prepared three types of Neapolitan pizza for them. The queen favored the version topped with tomatoes, mozzarella and basil.

That approval gave acclaim to pizza margherita — a type of Neapolitan pizza — and elevated pizza in Italy from a local dish to national status worthy of royal appetites.

Naturally, pizza margherita is on the menu at both 1889 and il Lazzarone. But for the sake of comparison, we recommend sampling the versions at Bella Napoli, Lazia in the Crossroads Hotel and Cupini’s, too.

Detroit-style pizza

Providence Pizza brought Detroit-style pizza from the Motor City to the Paris of the Plains. Rectangular in shape, this deep-dish style features a crispy, chewy focaccia-type crust that’s thick but fluffy in texture. Typically, the pizza is smothered in brick cheese.

At Providence, “the flavor combinations are consistently compelling, and the Frico — the lacy, browned cheese crisp that adorns the edges of the pie — is a fitting crown,” says Chaudry.

You can build your own Detroit-style pizza at Providence, but we recommend trying a slice of the Motor City, shown in the photo at top. It’s got pepperoni, basil and red sauce topped with a three-cheese blend and dollops of ricotta. Take one bite and you’ll be hooked.

Sicilian-style pizza

Moretina’s Caddy Shack also serves a Sicilian-style thin crust — round and topped with sauce inspired by a family recipe.

Sicilian pizza’s thick crust is soft and spongy, similar to focaccia, as a result of extended time that allows the dough to rise. Lining the rectangular or square baking pan with olive oil creates a crispy bottom crust, another signature trait. When ordering a Sicilian-style pizza, you can anticipate more sauce and cheese compared to a Neapolitan pizza.

Chaudry points to Providence Pizza’s Rezy as Kansas City’s best Sicilian-style slice. Topped with a pink vodka sauce, housemade fresh mozzarella, fresh basil and sesame seed crust, it’s another delicious choice at Providence.

You can also find Sicilian-style pizzas at Marco Polo’s Italian Market, located next to Jaspers in south Kansas City.

Grandma pizza

Hungry for pizza in Kansas City? Here's a guide to the city's many shops and styles (3)

Clay & Fire

/

Grandma pizza hails from Long Island, New York. The appellation refers to first-generation Italian grandmothers and mothers in the early 20th century who adapted to American kitchen ovens and sheet pans. No fancy pizza stone or other kitchenware is used.

Like Detroit-style pizza, it's usually rectangular shaped, but instead has a thin crust — with the cheese covering the dough first, and then the sauce. Long Island pizzerias adopted the homespun style as an homage to household nonne who made “pizza of the house.”

“I wouldn't have imagined that a Turkish restaurant would offer Kansas City's best Grandma Pizza, but there's no question that Clay & Fire tops the local list,” says Chaudry. “It's not entirely traditional to the style’s Long Island roots as their version is circular rather than rectangular, but the fresh basil and garlicky tomato topping is a celebration of sweet simplicity.”

To add another stamp of approval, Kansas City Magazine declared Clay & Fire’s Grandma Pizza their “Pie of the Year” in 2022.

New York-style pizza

Hungry for pizza in Kansas City? Here's a guide to the city's many shops and styles (4)

Zach Bauman

/

Pizza Tascio

No other style inspires heated debate about authenticity quite like New York-style pizza. We’re talking about a large hand-tossed crust spread thin with a thick, crispy edge, topped with red sauce and shredded mozzarella. You can zhuzh up a slice with a dusting of oregano, red chili flakes, honey or Parmesan cheese if you must.

New York-style slices are thin and pliable enough to fold, and made to eat on the go.

Until you book a plane ticket to the Big Apple, try these local options and see what you think.

“New York is still one of the most-imitated styles,” says Chaudry. “Leone’s Original Pizza in Overland Park is a nostalgic favorite for many but its appeal goes beyond nostalgia. It is still the closest thing to an authentic New York slice to be found in these parts.”

Erik Borger, the former owner of il Lazzarone, went back to his East Coast roots when he opened Pizza Tascio in North Kansas City. Borger’s obsession with ingredients, process and the pursuit of perfection is no surprise to local foodies and fans of his pies. You can also find Pizza Tascio locations on 39th Street in Kansas City, in St. Joseph, Overland Park and even Lawrence.

Elsewhere, Buffalo State Pizza serves massive slices and specialty pies made with premium toppings. In addition to Overland Park and Kansas City’s Crossroads Arts District, travelers will soon be able to enjoy their New York-style slices at Kansas City International Airport’s new terminal.

St. Louis-style pizza

Hungry for pizza in Kansas City? Here's a guide to the city's many shops and styles (5)

Brian Munoz

/

KCUR 89.3

Any self-respecting native Kansas Citian would shudder at the sight of St. Louis-style pizza. Distinctive for its thin, cracker-like crust and cut into rectangular pieces, you can’t really fold a slice of St. Louis-style pizza.

The style’s other signature trait is the use of Provel cheese, a processed mixture of provolone, Swiss and white cheddar cheeses. Provel is not used in other pizza styles, and in fact, the blend isn’t widely available outside of the St. Louis area.

Good-natured trash talk aside, St. Louis-style pizza has a rich history worth exploring and tasting, whether this regional style inspires cringing or craving. Besides, Kansas City doesn’t have its own established style.

Maybe Missourians should embrace this contribution from St. Louis… maybe.

St. Louis-style pizza is available at Imo’s Pizza in Kansas City and Overland Park — this St. Louis-based chain may not be the style's inventor, but it's the shop that popularized and remains most famous (or infamous) for it today.

Popular south Kansas City destination Waldo’s Pizza takes the style to the next level, using a combination of mozzarella, provolone, Swiss, cheddar and muenster cheeses, with garlic butter for good measure.

Chicago-style, bar pizza and other noteworthy mentions

Hungry for pizza in Kansas City? Here's a guide to the city's many shops and styles (6)

Third Coast Pizza

/

Finding an authentic Chicago-style pizza outside the Windy City is no simple task, even here in Kansas City. Thankfully, Chicago-style pizza fans can delight in the deep dish at Third Coast Pizza, located in Lenexa, Kansas. Third Coast recreates a taste of Chicago with gut-pleasing results.

Sometimes a good bar pizza — thick and loaded with toppings — doesn’t align to one particular style. Minsky’s is well-known here, but don’t overlook Martin City Pizza and Guy’s Deli & Pizza (formerly Joe’s Pizza) in Westport.

Last but not least, Pizza Shuttle doesn’t represent a style as much as it is a lifestyle. It’s a slice of hot, greasy nostalgia, especially for Jayhawks. University of Kansas alumni, undergraduates and local pizza fans can get their Pizza Shuttle fix in Lawrence, Overland Park and Kansas City’s Crossroads.

Did we miss any other notable pizza styles in Kansas City, or forget about any notable must-try parlors? Drop us a line!

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Duane Harber

Last Updated: 02/28/2023

Views: 6101

Rating: 4 / 5 (51 voted)

Reviews: 82% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Duane Harber

Birthday: 1999-10-17

Address: Apt. 404 9899 Magnolia Roads, Port Royceville, ID 78186

Phone: +186911129794335

Job: Human Hospitality Planner

Hobby: Listening to music, Orienteering, Knapping, Dance, Mountain biking, Fishing, Pottery

Introduction: My name is Duane Harber, I am a modern, clever, handsome, fair, agreeable, inexpensive, beautiful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.